Optimal Tax Setup for Fully Digital Professional Services Firm

[JustAnotherNomad]

I know there are genuinely nomadic people, look at my username.
Makes sense then.

 

[vs90]

Has someone ever looked into a US LLC as a passthrough entity + Malta non-dom resident?

Let's assume that 1) the US LLC is effectively managed by someone else in another non-US and non-Maltese country, so it does not trigger US or Malta tax residency, and 2) the person can sustain their annual expenses with remitted foreign capital gains from capital they had before entering Malta.

If the US LCC profits are sent to a non-Maltese bank account, could the Malta taxation be only the annual 5k?

Could the above work if the US LLC also has income from US clients?

This would be much simpler and cheaper than having a Malta trading + Cyprus/Estonia holding that provides foreign non-remitted dividends to a UBO that is still a Maltese resident.

 

[daniels27]

Has someone ever looked into a US LLC as a passthrough entity + Malta non-dom resident?

Let's assume that 1) the US LLC is effectively managed by someone else in another non-US and non-Maltese country, so it does not trigger US or Malta tax residency, and 2) the person can sustain their annual expenses with remitted foreign capital gains from capital they had before entering Malta.

If the US LCC profits are sent to a non-Maltese bank account, could the Malta taxation be only the annual 5k?

Could the above work if the US LLC also has income from US clients?

This would be much simpler and cheaper than having a Malta trading + Cyprus/Estonia holding that provides foreign non-remitted dividends to a UBO that is still a Maltese resident.

It is it managed from outside Malta and outside the US, you need to know where it is managed from and check if it would trigger any PE there. If they won't care or otherwise not an issue. You can get "dividends" in Malta from your US LLC. You would only pay what they charge you in Malta. I think @disagree is considering the same to enjoy flat taxes at 5k EUR per year.

 

[disagree]

It is it managed from outside Malta and outside the US, you need to know where it is managed from and check if it would trigger any PE there. If they won't care or otherwise not an issue. You can get "dividends" in Malta from your US LLC. You would only pay what they charge you in Malta. I think @disagree is considering the same to enjoy flat taxes at 5k EUR per year.

it's the super-duper-widely popular solutions for Malta non-dom residents. Basically Malta doesn't enforce PE at all. Plus, they treat LLCs as opaque entities.
They don't really care about what you're doing outside of Malta. They charge this 5k one shot fee per year if you declare you had foreign income above 35.000 €. At the same time they never had any type of enforcement activity for this, so the truth is that a lot of people just file at 0 every year also while making multiple six figures a year. Not suggesting to do this. Just telling what's happening.
It's one of those setups where the "they don't really care" concept find it's perfect application.

Edit: I have to be more precise about the 5K one shot tax and the 35K threshold.
As far as I know, if you don’t remit foreign income to Malta, you are not subject to the €5.000 minimum tax, even if your foreign income exceeds €35K

If you are a non-domiciled resident in Malta you are subject to a taxation system called remittance basis where you're only taxed on 1) income generated in malta and 2) foreign income remitted to Malta. Foreign income not remitted to Malta is completely exempt from taxes regardless of the amount.

The €5K one shot tax applies in some cases. For example: if your total taxable income (Malta-sourced income + foreign income remitted to Malta) exceeds €35K
If the total tax calculated on your taxable income is less than €5K, you will be required to pay the difference to meet the €5K minimum

That said... if you do not remit any foreign income to Malta, you are not subject to the €5K tax, even if your foreign income is above €35K. The issue (for someone) is that also paying for your rent or other services like internet, etc are theoretically "remitted"

 

[vs90]

I got it, it makes sense. Such a setup could be sensible if someone lives with foreign capital gains, which are then remitted tax-free (except the annual 5k.)

To make this compliant the LLC would have to be managed by someone else and not in Malta, although Malta would probably not care too much.

Do you know how people in this setup deal with bank accounts, transferring money from USD to EUR, etc.?

 

[disagree]

I got it, it makes sense. Such a setup could be sensible if someone lives with foreign capital gains, which are then remitted tax-free (except the annual 5k.)

To make this compliant the LLC would have to be managed by someone else and not in Malta, although Malta would probably not care too much.

Do you know how people in this setup deal with bank accounts, transferring money from USD to EUR, etc.?

Capital gains are never taxed in Malta, also if remitted. They're not considered the same way as revenue.
At the same time I can't see why you should remit that.

With a couple foreign bank accounts and fintech solutions, you're ok. Consider that thanks to the agility of this setup, let's say you have both Wise Business (LLC) and Wise personal (Malta), it's just matter of seconds and you can move money into your personal one and spend, or move somewhere else without remitting.

 

[vs90]

Capital gains are never taxed in Malta, also if remitted. They're not considered the same way as revenue.
At the same time I can't see why you should remit that.

Because you'll have to pay for living expenses. If they are foreign capital gains, they'll be tax free. But as far as I know you still have to pay the 5k minimum tax.

With a couple foreign bank accounts and fintech solutions, you're ok. Consider that thanks to the agility of this setup, let's say you have both Wise Business (LLC) and Wise personal (Malta), it's just matter of seconds and you can move money into your personal one and spend, or move somewhere else without remitting.

Makes sense!

 

[disagree]

Because you'll have to pay for living expenses. If they are foreign capital gains, they'll be tax free. But as far as I know you still have to pay the 5k minimum tax.



Makes sense!

In that case you should pay the 5K, but based on money you use for big living expenses like rent, not for capital gains even if remitted.
As I said, the truth is nobody care.

 

[vs90]

I have been speaking with a few providers for the following setup:

• Malta Trading Co + Foreign Holding Co set up as a fiscal unit to achieve the 5% corporate tax
• The idea is that I won't remit into Malta the foreign dividend because I can cover the cost of living with remitted foreign capital gains
• I am also thinking to pay a small salary as the Maltese MD up to the 5k tax I'd have to pay anyway (plus the associated social contributions)

One of these providers has mentioned two things:

1. Estonia is better than Cyprus because:
   1. Bank account opening in Malta with a Cyprus Holding and a Maltese non-dom resident as UBO is hard. Did anyone experience the same?
   2. Estonia is cheaper and more efficient (this I know to be true)
2. It's not recommended to form a fiscal unit in the first year. That's because this would require consolidated statements, which will make it clear to the Maltese authorities that the UBO is a Maltese non-dom resident who is also the MD of the Maltese trading company. Are they right?

Additionally:

1. Is it a good idea to receive a small salary as the Maltese MD? I don't need it for cash flows, I could just bring in more foreign capital gains. But I thought it could be good to show substance in Malta and that I pay social contributions somewhere?
2. What is a fair price for Year 1 and ongoing for both entities? The trading has about 5-10 incoming invoices and 5-10 outgoing invoices every month, whereas the holding would only deal with the annual dividends and in the future maybe some other investments

 

[Don]

I have been speaking with a few providers for the following setup:

• Malta Trading Co + Foreign Holding Co set up as a fiscal unit to achieve the 5% corporate tax
• The idea is that I won't remit into Malta the foreign dividend because I can cover the cost of living with remitted foreign capital gains
• I am also thinking to pay a small salary as the Maltese MD up to the 5k tax I'd have to pay anyway (plus the associated social contributions)

One of these providers has mentioned two things:

1. Estonia is better than Cyprus because:
   1. Bank account opening in Malta with a Cyprus Holding and a Maltese non-dom resident as UBO is hard. Did anyone experience the same?
   2. Estonia is cheaper and more efficient (this I know to be true)
2. It's not recommended to form a fiscal unit in the first year. That's because this would require consolidated statements, which will make it clear to the Maltese authorities that the UBO is a Maltese non-dom resident who is also the MD of the Maltese trading company. Are they right?

Additionally:

1. Is it a good idea to receive a small salary as the Maltese MD? I don't need it for cash flows, I could just bring in more foreign capital gains. But I thought it could be good to show substance in Malta and that I pay social contributions somewhere?

Yes, why not, and get public health insurance this way.

1. What is a fair price for Year 1 and ongoing for both entities? The trading has about 5-10 incoming invoices and 5-10 outgoing invoices every month, whereas the holding would only deal with the annual dividends and in the future maybe some other investments

Business transactions are based on mutually agreed terms, not moral fairness.
That being said buying professional services is not equal to filling up your cars gas tank.
The price you get is most likely influenced by the risk level of your business and yourself as a person.