Our valued sponsor

AMA: I've made a mobile app (App Store & Google Play) with in-app purchases and it's anonymous

Hi! Not sure what you mean by DND developer account? What I have done is creating a google payments account with the details of a US-based person, create a Google Dev account with it and have ways to show that this person is related to the business. MAYBE there can be other ways too.
Sorry, was a typo. Should have read "a developer account". But what I meant was that actually you do not need a US person but just a US payments profile?
 
Sorry, was a typo. Should have read "a developer account". But what I meant was that actually you do not need a US person but just a US payments profile?
That US payments profile has to belong to somebody who is a US resident or maybe just a US national living abroad, and you need to be able to bring evidence that the person is related to the business.
 
That US payments profile has to belong to somebody who is a US resident or maybe just a US national living abroad, and you need to be able to bring evidence that the person is related to the business.
Yes, I think the evidence is clear. But what I am wondering is what it needs. Of course not a US passport. It would be interesting if a US payment profile is enough.
 
How can the US payment profile on Google be enough, when it's basically the one thing you are trying to validate???

What I did was a change in the operating agreement of my company and a scan of a Mercury bank card in the name of the company and with the name of the person in the payments profile.
 
How can the US payment profile on Google be enough, when it's basically the one thing you are trying to validate???

What I did was a change in the operating agreement of my company and a scan of a Mercury bank card in the name of the company and with the name of the person in the payments profile.
Ok, so they want a US bank card?
 
Do you realise I wrote "What I did was A and B" and you replied "So they want A?"

I don't know what they want.
Nobody knows what they want.

All I can say is that the two things I have provided (including ID of the person on the payments account) worked.

There are no specific "to do lists" from Google, and whoever you get in touch with from support, either via phone or in writing, will be quite clueless and will have no playbook from which to direct you. There's no dialogue. You submit stuff. If they like it, you pass verification. If they don't, they fail you and you have to submit something else. But at no point is anybody able to tell you what's wrong and what's right.
 
My advice for the next guy would be to actually read and understand what I wrote in very uncomplicated English.
I think we all understood your advice and it is appreciated. But not everybody can afford a US nominee, while opening a US payment profile literally costs nothing but 5 minutes of work. That's why it would be interesting to find out what is actually needed for it to work. In any case, I am not going to open this, I am just trying to help those that come here later and don't want to spend money on nominees.
 
Last edited:
If you think you can beat Google at their own game of ignorance, elective mutism and disregard for their users, why don't you show us how it's done, instead of asking to others to throw themselves in the fire and "report back"?
Hey, calm down. I am just trying to help those that come here. If it was free, I woud of course already have done this and reported myself.
 
Ok, I've dug up the documents I had sent.

As of last summer (2024), the options for the payment account owner to identify themselves as being based in (or being sufficiently related to) the geography of the business (the US in this case) and as the person that is, ultimately, authorised to submit a W8BEN (through the same screens for this whole verification) on behalf of the UBO of the business are (exactly as listed by Google):

Driver's licence
Passport
Taxpayer Certificate
Other Government ID

plus a "Reasonable Written Explanation" (with the previously mentioned evidence) as to how this person is involved in the business.

In other words, unless you want to have fun with forgery, I'd wager you need a US national (based anywhere?) or a non-US national based in the US.
 
  • Like
Reactions: daniels27
Ok, I've dug up the documents I had sent.

As of last summer (2024), the options for the payment account owner to identify themselves as being based in (or being sufficiently related to) the geography of the business (the US in this case) and as the person that is, ultimately, authorised to submit a W8BEN (through the same screens for this whole verification) on behalf of the UBO of the business are (exactly as listed by Google):

Driver's licence
Passport
Taxpayer Certificate
Other Government ID

plus a "Reasonable Written Explanation" (with the previously mentioned evidence) as to how this person is involved in the business.

In other words, unless you want to have fun with forgery, I'd wager you need a US national (based anywhere?) or a non-US national based in the US.
Thanks. Your help is appreciated. In this case, you could taxe the driving exam in New York and then use that licence. Would require you to be able to travel to the US as tourist though.
 
Sounds like a possibility, but remember guess we are ultimately at the mercy of, most likely, some bot/AI deciding on this.
Plus I wonder if documentation of that kind in your name might be a challenge further down if you are trying to show no substance in the US. Google itself might challenge your W8BEN (as opposed to a W9) if you are also the person of the payments account?
 
  • Like
Reactions: daniels27
Sounds like a possibility, but remember guess we are ultimately at the mercy of, most likely, some bot/AI deciding on this.
Plus I wonder if documentation of that kind in your name might be a challenge further down if you are trying to show no substance in the US. Google itself might challenge your W8BEN (as opposed to a W9) if you are also the person of the payments account?
In theory, you can even send a W-9 as the IRS ultimately charges taxes. And there, the IRS states, that you should send W-8BEN forms. Note that this does not necessarily apply for U.S. Territories (Puerto Rico, American Samoa, U.S. Virgin Islands, Guam, Northern Mariuana Islands).
 
@drillbill @kissandorzsolti @saeed

Big disclaimer: you need somebody US-based whom you can trust, can be involved in your business at least on paper, and that can create a google payments account for you

What I did after a few fails which involved creating additional dev accounts for google was
- create an email address in the domain of my company with the name of a relative of mine who is US based
- create a payments profile on google with that email
- test that it worked in some way or another (I must have made a purchase, I guess)
- only then did I create the google dev account with that e-mail address and payments profile (paid the $25 dollar fee with the payments profile)
- transferred the app to the new account (I had zero trust in the google migration functionality so I had the dev to create a new bundle from scratch)
- redacted the operating agreement of my company to include that relative as a manager (not a member)
- created a physical bank card in the name of the relative (Mercury is great for this)
- when the time for that verification came, I submitted the relative's passport, their bank card and the operating agreement as evidence of them being US based and the payments account being in their name

the last bit was difficult because the form on the developer console is very ambiguous, it's hard to understand when they are referring to you (the owner) or to the payments account holder. I remember being failed a couple of times, getting in touch with support who couldn't really help (usual case of not very literate/fluent people), but ultimately I got it.

Yes, it's shocking, I know. All of this I had to figure out by myself. Have a look at this, try to chase that BenMcc guy on that support.google.com, he's ex-Google I think and the only person remotely knowledgeable.
https://support.google.com/googlepl...d/241004070?hl=en&sjid=2599851225550045132-NA

As you can see, it's a problem that very many have.
Maybe things have changed for the better now.


Another thing that's important is the DUNS number. Be careful D&B don't make your name and surname visible through some of the searches (they had different ones).https://www.dnb.com/business-directory.html#BusinessDirectoryPageNumber=1&ContactDirectoryPageNumber=1&MarketplacePageNumber=1&SiteContentPageNumber=1&tab=Business Directory
^ this is the one that can inadvertedly publish your personal details too.
In the case, you have to get in touch with them and get it removed, explaining very well with screenshots etc etc.
Again, it's amazing the number of truly dim people working these sort of customer service roles.
Thanks so much for your detailed explanation on how to go about it. I was already aware that I’d need to find someone in the U.S. to act as a frontman or middleman. I’ve actually started looking for someone to take on the task, but it’s been a bit tricky so far.
 
Thanks so much for your detailed explanation on how to go about it. I was already aware that I’d need to find someone in the U.S. to act as a frontman or middleman. I’ve actually started looking for someone to take on the task, but it’s been a bit tricky so far.
You're welcome. Maybe it's not the end of the world for a registered agent to be that person, if you have one.