Our valued sponsor

Reducing taxes by cashing out every couple of years

JustAnotherNomad

Pro Member
Oct 18, 2019
3,282
1,692
1,905
Register now
You must login or register to view hidden content on this page.
I guess I could have posted this as a reply to this thread, but it's slightly more specific, so I figured a new thread might be in order.

I don't remember who suggested this originally, was it @TheCryptoAnt or @wellington ?
Anyway, someone mentioned they live in Thailand full time, living off dividends which they receive every couple of years.
So during a "payout year", they just spend less than 180 days in Thailand and their income isn't taxed in Thailand.

As much as I like Thailand, I have been wondering if something similar could work elsewhere (in a first-world country), and Switzerland seems like a good candidate:
For example:
- Set up a company in a low-tax canton like Zug
- Live in a place with low taxes, like Glarus (or wherever taxes are low) - Switzerland is small, so even if you live in the middle of nowhere, it's never far from a major city
- Only pay out what you need to live - not sure if salary or dividends would be better, probably not a big difference
- Optional: Add a holding company in a country without withholding tax (Cyprus, Malta, Estonia, ...) or use a Swiss branch instead of a Swiss subsidiary - the point is that you can transfer dividends to the parent entity without paying Swiss WHT
- The holding company shouldn't be a problem, as long as you have some substance, as Switzerland doesn't have CFC rules, which makes it an ideal candidate (in most other countries, this could be an issue)
- Every couple of years, you move to e.g. Dubai and spend 183+ days there - this is when you cash out from your holding company
- Alternatively, you could also move to Estonia/Cyprus/Malta/maybe Hong Kong?, then you wouldn't even need a holding company, as Switzerland doesn't impose WHT on dividends paid to those countries
- Switzerland doesn't have an exit tax for individuals, so moving abroad shouldn't trigger tax, as long as your business remains in Switzerland
- It's a Schengen country, so if you really live in e.g. Italy, France, Spain... would be hard to track (certainly not in focus for the authorities if you're not a citizen of those countries)
- It's possible to get a binding confirmation from the Swiss tax office that your setup will work, even before you move to the country - it's not like Dubai or Cyprus where three advisors will give you five different answers.

This would allow one to live in a proper first-world country in Europe (not a place like Cyprus or Malta) while paying minimal taxes, basically only 10-11% or so in corporate income taxes + some tax for the money you pay out while living in Switzerland.
Heck, you could probably even set up another entity in a low- or zero-tax jurisdiction and shift profits there, as long as there is some substance, since Switzerland doesn't have CFC rules. For example, Malta only has 5% CIT.

Anything I'm missing?
Also tagging @Marzio since he usually has good ideas. :D
 
That sounds like a great idea. Dubai now has a 9% corporate tax, so there might not be much advantage in having a holding company in Dubai owning the company in Switzerland. Are there perhaps other countries that could work well as a holding jurisdiction where no tax is paid on the income received from the operating company in Switzerland?
 
  • Dislike
Reactions: JustAnotherNomad
1. Where did I suggest using a holding company in Dubai? There's 5% WHT in Switzerland. Please read what I wrote. Heck, I even wrote how doing business in the UAE absolutely sucks. And you ask if "perhaps other countries could work as a holding jurisdiction", yeah, how about the ones I literally LISTED IN MY POST? Why do I have to deal with comments like this...

2. UAE holding companies are exempt from corporate income tax, so not even that part is correct.
 
Every couple of years, you move to e.g. Dubai and spend 183+ days there - this is when you cash out from your holding company

It could work but:

1. in the cash out year you can't stay in CH for more than 29 days otherwise you'll be considered tax resident. (this assuming you don't have any other ties in CH).

2. regardless of point 1 i have the feeling that the chocolate lovers will try to tax you anyway unless you demonstrate that for that year you were tax resident somewhere else.

3. i don't know if CH will be fine with the fact that you are losing CH tax residency every other year. In a way this could demonstrate that you don't have the intention to permanently establish your usual abode in Switzerland but....remeber that it's the country where you are not allowed to hang up laundry outside on Sundays so you'll never know WTF they have in their mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: daniels27 and ilke
I guess I could have posted this as a reply to this thread, but it's slightly more specific, so I figured a new thread might be in order.

I don't remember who suggested this originally, was it @TheCryptoAnt or @wellington ?
Anyway, someone mentioned they live in Thailand full time, living off dividends which they receive every couple of years.
So during a "payout year", they just spend less than 180 days in Thailand and their income isn't taxed in Thailand.

As much as I like Thailand, I have been wondering if something similar could work elsewhere (in a first-world country), and Switzerland seems like a good candidate:
For example:
- Set up a company in a low-tax canton like Zug
- Live in a place with low taxes, like Glarus (or wherever taxes are low) - Switzerland is small, so even if you live in the middle of nowhere, it's never far from a major city
- Only pay out what you need to live - not sure if salary or dividends would be better, probably not a big difference
- Optional: Add a holding company in a country without withholding tax (Cyprus, Malta, Estonia, ...) or use a Swiss branch instead of a Swiss subsidiary - the point is that you can transfer dividends to the parent entity without paying Swiss WHT
- The holding company shouldn't be a problem, as long as you have some substance, as Switzerland doesn't have CFC rules, which makes it an ideal candidate (in most other countries, this could be an issue)
- Every couple of years, you move to e.g. Dubai and spend 183+ days there - this is when you cash out from your holding company
- Alternatively, you could also move to Estonia/Cyprus/Malta/maybe Hong Kong?, then you wouldn't even need a holding company, as Switzerland doesn't impose WHT on dividends paid to those countries
- Switzerland doesn't have an exit tax for individuals, so moving abroad shouldn't trigger tax, as long as your business remains in Switzerland
- It's a Schengen country, so if you really live in e.g. Italy, France, Spain... would be hard to track (certainly not in focus for the authorities if you're not a citizen of those countries)
- It's possible to get a binding confirmation from the Swiss tax office that your setup will work, even before you move to the country - it's not like Dubai or Cyprus where three advisors will give you five different answers.

This would allow one to live in a proper first-world country in Europe (not a place like Cyprus or Malta) while paying minimal taxes, basically only 10-11% or so in corporate income taxes + some tax for the money you pay out while living in Switzerland.
Heck, you could probably even set up another entity in a low- or zero-tax jurisdiction and shift profits there, as long as there is some substance, since Switzerland doesn't have CFC rules. For example, Malta only has 5% CIT.

Anything I'm missing?
Also tagging @Marzio since he usually has good ideas. :D
no, this doesnt work. You will have to stay away for many years.
 
1. Where did I suggest using a holding company in Dubai? There's 5% WHT in Switzerland. Please read what I wrote. Heck, I even wrote how doing business in the UAE absolutely sucks. And you ask if "perhaps other countries could work as a holding jurisdiction", yeah, how about the ones I literally LISTED IN MY POST? Why do I have to deal with comments like this...

2. UAE holding companies are exempt from corporate income tax, so not even that part is correct.
I think you are overreacting in your post, which is probably why there aren’t more people commenting here! Your aggressive response is completely unnecessary and silly. Not everyone knows everything, and we are all here to learn and share knowledge, not to be unkind.
 
Yeah, this was my concern as well. CH is not Thailand
well they have a entrenched and big welfare state in ch where even the foreigners get some (more or less questionable) benefits like healthcare, pensions and the likes plus theres easy job market access for all eu passport holders.
This is all not available like that in thailand and or only after some heavy lifting, so it makes sense it being very different.
 
What you are able to do in a mismanaged State like Thailand because there is only one single tax residence condition - staying at least 180 days per calendar year in TH - is not something I would try in any Western/EU country. Risk is high they will eventually find out, fine and tax you because it's obvious you structure yourself in order to avoid paying taxes.
 
well they have a entrenched and big welfare state in ch where even the foreigners get some (more or less questionable) benefits like healthcare, pensions and the likes plus theres easy job market access for all eu passport holders.
But it’s nothing compared to Denmark. There, you don’t have to do a thing, just sit back and wait for someone to knock on your door and tell you the state’s got you covered, even if you’re not from Denmark. And guess who’s footing the bill? All the taxpayers getting screwed over by that ridiculous tax system.

That said I can imagine there are some valid points in OP's strategy that easily could work from Switzerland.
 
But it’s nothing compared to Denmark. There, you don’t have to do a thing, just sit back and wait for someone to knock on your door and tell you the state’s got you covered, even if you’re not from Denmark. And guess who’s footing the bill? All the taxpayers getting screwed over by that ridiculous tax system.

That said I can imagine there are some valid points in OP's strategy that easily could work from Switzerland.
well yeah like Dante already said: the (socialist) hell consists of multiple layers.
 
What you are able to do in a mismanaged State like Thailand because there is only one single tax residence condition - staying at least 180 days per calendar year in TH - is not something I would try in any Western/EU country. Risk is high they will eventually find out, fine and tax you because it's obvious you structure yourself in order to avoid paying taxes.

Obviously I wouldn't just try this, but get a binding ruling from the tax authority in advance, etc.
They would have to follow the treaty - so as long as you go to a treaty country for the whole year, I can't really see how they could still consider your tax resident in that year.
Well, I guess you would probably have to give up your apartment, but maybe you can just rent it out for the year you're gone...
 
  • Like
Reactions: gyorgy
1. Where did I suggest using a holding company in Dubai? There's 5% WHT in Switzerland. Please read what I wrote. Heck, I even wrote how doing business in the UAE absolutely sucks. And you ask if "perhaps other countries could work as a holding jurisdiction", yeah, how about the ones I literally LISTED IN MY POST? Why do I have to deal with comments like this...

2. UAE holding companies are exempt from corporate income tax, so not even that part is correct.
The holding companies in UAE that are being referred to must be in Freezones only then they are zero taxed.My point is if we need to use freezones eventually why not use freezones elsewhere in the world.Dubai is expensive other places are not.
 
The holding companies in UAE that are being referred to must be in Freezones only then they are zero taxed.My point is if we need to use freezones eventually why not use freezones elsewhere in the world.Dubai is expensive other places are not.
Do you know many freezones outside of UAE that are trivial & cheaper to get into? I checked free zones in Georgia and they had very ambiguous tax rules that can backfire for some use cases. Armenian ones are impossible to get into unless you have deep ties in the gov.
 
I don’t see this as workable. Firstly you don’t say what nationality you are? Make a big impact.

Also it’s not easy to just come and go as a Swiss resident, there’s a lot of admin around both registering and de-registering.

The Swiss social security will also want a claim on your income. Etc etc

Better to be resident elsewhere and spend time in Switzerland, or just bite the bullet and go for low tax not no tax
 
I don’t see this as workable. Firstly you don’t say what nationality you are? Make a big impact.

Also it’s not easy to just come and go as a Swiss resident, there’s a lot of admin around both registering and de-registering.

The Swiss social security will also want a claim on your income. Etc etc

Better to be resident elsewhere and spend time in Switzerland, or just bite the bullet and go for low tax not no tax
My country leaves me alone if i am outside for 6 months so no taxes to pay if i am not in the country for more than 6 months,does that help.A little reluctant to give my nationality here.
 
Last edited:
I don't remember who suggested this originally, was it @TheCryptoAnt or @wellington ?
Anyway, someone mentioned they live in Thailand full time, living off dividends which they receive every couple of years.
So during a "payout year", they just spend less than 180 days in Thailand and their income isn't taxed in Thailand.
Quick response (as Brit citizenship)

Previously could just get dividends in Nov and transfer in Jan tax free.

Now you've got to leave the country to get them tax free, and then return. (6 months floating around).
 
The idea would be to use a treaty to be tax resident elsewhere. One could still be resident in Switzerland.
 
Register now
You must login or register to view hidden content on this page.